Balan answered the phone on a Monday night, the eve of Cyclone Murasu making landfall. It was his brother Kuppan, who had gone out fishing from Kasimedu with the rest of the crew.
It was around 10:30 pm. Kuppan told him what was happening on the water: strong winds and heavy rain had damaged the boat, and the engine had stopped. They had called nearby boats to come and get them out.
The skipper, Pakkirisamy, whom everyone called Suriya, had called too. He told the owner about the wind, the dead engine and the water coming into the hull, and asked for help. To his wife, Parvathi, he did not say how serious it was. He promised he would be home to celebrate Deepavali with the family.
Another boat was anchored beside theirs. Over the radio they warned that the sea was flooding the engine room. But the other boat was taking on water too, and in that weather it could not come closer.
Before help could come, the boat capsized.
On Friday, five bodies arrived in Kasimedu. Kuppan's was one of them.
Balan says the men had also told the owner about the wind and the engine. And then he adds: "Now, our family cannot even see his face".
Scene reconstructed from documented behaviour and territory; sources at the foot of the article.
The signal
On 29 October, the Sri Sengalamman, registration TN 02 MM 2584, left Kasimedu fishing harbour in Chennai with nine crew. According to the Coast Guard, it sailed after Cyclone Arnab made landfall and, with Murasu forecast to arrive on the night of 2 to 3 November between Nellore and Narsapur, took shelter in Nizampatnam, in Andhra Pradesh (News On AIR). Three other Tamil Nadu boats were waiting at anchor in Ramayapatnam port.
The fatal move was leaving shelter. The nine left Nizampatnam for Ramayapatnam to join their colleagues aboard another boat "without informing authorities in either Andhra Pradesh or Tamil Nadu beforehand", writes The South First, drawing on the account of the Prakasam collector, P. Raja Babu. That paper dates the departure to 3 November; The News Minute, to the 2nd. On the way, the boat was anchored alongside another and both drifted with the wind. Over VHF radio, the crew reported water flooding the engine room; the second boat was taking on water too and could not get close.
As of 7 November, the Coast Guard and The News Minute count seven dead and two missing. The dead are Mohan, Murugan, Pakkirisamy, Vijayakanth, Kuppusamy, Kuppan and Aravindh, from Royapuram, RK Nagar, Thiruvottiyur and Tondiarpet. Still missing are Rajesh, of Thiruchinankuppam, and Narayanan, of Samiyarpettai (DT Next).
What is new is an official admission. Tamil Nadu Finance Minister N. Marie Wilson told reporters the boat "lacked mandatory safety gear, proper commercial insurance, and vital regulatory documents", and promised to tighten maritime safety protocols (PTI, 6 November). Tamil Nadu Fisheries officials added that the navigation transponder was not working: it had been under repair (The South First, 5 November).
The context
The accounts do not match. Tamil Nadu's Fisheries Director, K. Vijayakarthikeyan, maintains that the government ordered the search as soon as it learned of the disappearance, that the Coast Guard flew two helicopter patrols and that the department has records of everything (DT Next, paraphrased). The Coast Guard says the boat "did not pay heed to the advisories issued by all the concerned agencies". The families answer that timely action would have saved the men, and blame the owner, Selvalagan, and the Coast Guard itself.
Underneath lies an older dispute. On the same trip to Ongole, Wilson asked Andhra Pradesh to release eight Tamil Nadu boats seized more than three months ago, worth about Rs 5 crore, and said Tamil Nadu would make its fishers respect the restrictions on fishing in Andhra waters (The News Minute, citing The Hans India).
The government is paying Rs 7 lakh per family, Rs 2 lakh of it immediately, and bringing the bodies home at its own expense. One relative, Balan, Kuppan's brother, also says the boat had no permit or insurance and that four of the nine were new to the trade (DT Next). The insurance and the papers were later confirmed by the minister. The newcomers remain his word alone.
The reading
The simple hypothesis, that it was the cyclone, explains the wreck but not the decision. The boat did not go to sea with Murasu: it was in shelter. What needs explaining is why a Chennai crew, sheltering in another state's port, moved in the cyclone's window without either administration knowing.
The sources give two motives: joining their colleagues on the other boat, according to the collector, and getting home for Deepavali, according to the skipper's family. None mentions debt or the season, and neither is assumed here.
What they do show is where the boat stood on the administrative map. For Tamil Nadu it was a boat under its own registration that, as its minister admits, lacked insurance and documents. For Andhra Pradesh it was another state's boat, on a coast where eight like it have been held for three months. In that position, reporting in is not a neutral formality. No source says the crew kept quiet for fear of seizure, and this piece does not claim it. It is the question the case leaves open: whom does a boat notify when, for one state, it has no papers and, for the other, it should not be there?
The counterweight is serious. The Coast Guard says the advisories existed and were ignored, and that may be true. The reading stands: an alert reaches everyone alike, but it only protects those who are inside the system that issues it and follow it. A boat whose movement no one recorded also falls outside the search, which begins when someone reports it missing.
That is why, when everything fails, each authority has a culprit at hand: Tamil Nadu, the owner; the Coast Guard, the fishers; the families, the rescue.
The pattern
On a shared coast, the border between states cannot be seen in the water, but it decides who knows where each boat is. When a crew works in a neighbour's waters, its own state's register stops following it and the other state treats it as an offender. That leaves a strip with no one in charge. There, the border decides before the alert does: the cyclone warning reaches everyone alike, but the rescue depends on who knew.
The fishing dispute between Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh did not start this week; the eight seized boats prove it. What is new is that the Tamil Nadu government admitted in public, within days, that the boat had no insurance or papers. That admission shifts the blame onto the owner and, at the same time, may open a path for the families to claim beyond the compensation.
Declared gaps: The South First dates the departure from Nizampatnam to 3 November and The News Minute to the 2nd; Kuppan's call, on Monday the 2nd at around 10:30 pm, fits either. The four newcomers and the permit rest on a single voice, Balan's; the insurance and the documents, by contrast, were confirmed by the minister. The words of the Fisheries Director, the Prakasam collector and SI Subbarao are paraphrased: no open source carries a direct quote from them. The text of the IMD advisory to fishers was not opened, and neither the owner Selvalagan's account nor that of the Kasimedu fishers' association was found. In DT Next, Balan's line "cannot even see his face" follows the mention of the owner; it is unclear whom it refers to, and it is not interpreted here.
The links this piece cites, gathered and checked. Open them to verify.
- DT Next, “'They feared for their lives': kin in Chennai recall final call with fishers killed by Cyclone Murasu”, 2026-11-06 TIER B
- The South First, “Cyclone Murasu proves fatal for fishermen: four bodies wash ashore at Kothapatnam coast”, 2026-11-05 TIER B
- The News Minute, “Seven Tamil Nadu fishermen found dead after boat capsizes off Andhra coast”, 2026-11-07 TIER B
- Deccan Chronicle (PTI), “Search for 5 fishermen missing in AP intensified: TN govt”, 2026-11-06 TIER B
- News On AIR, “Tamil Nadu: Indian Coast Guard clarifies fishermen violated advisory regarding sea venturing during cyclones”, 2026-11-07 TIER B